Jorge Posada Played 17 years for one team Five-time all-star caught for four World Series champs. 42.7 WAR, 17.3 WAA Pro argument: Excellent offensive catcher who was a staple for dominant Yankees. Con argument: Does not line up favorably against Hall of Fame catchers.
Ballot 19: Jorge Posada
Jorge Posada Played 17 years for one team Five-time all-star caught for four World Series champs. 42.7 WAR, 17.3 WAA Pro argument: Excellent offensive catcher who was a staple for dominant Yankees. Con argument: Does not line up favorably against Hall of Fame catchers.
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to JoeBlogs to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.